Skip Navigation Links
Archive Home
Robinson v. Bates
Privilege/Authorizations

Welcome to the Archive

This archive is for sharing briefs, opinions, and other documents with our colleagues.
At this time, we are focusing our efforts on gathering documents concerning Robinson v. Bates (2006), 112 Ohio St.3d 17, 2006-Ohio-6362, and now, with defeating requests for authorizations for documents that are not causally and historically related to the issues in the litigation. However, we welcome input on any other matters and hope this will become a valuable resource to all.
This page has the complete archive. We have added new pages that limit the list to cases and documents dealing with Robinson v. Bates and Privilege and Authorizations respectively.
Registered users can add, and will be notified of, new documents and comments.
If you have comments or suggestions about this site, please
contact us.



187 documents archived
Filter by Tag:
Filter by Court:
Filter by Judge:
If you would like to add files, please register or login

 TitleCaptionCourt/JurisdictionJudgeCase No.CitationDocument DateFavored Party
Journal EntryJensen v. Hydracrete Pumoing Co., Inc.Cuyahoga County Common PleasBrian J. CorriganCV-08-648500 4/17/2009Favorable to Defendant
Entry Granting Plaintiff's Motion in Limine Regarding Insurance PaymentsHeenan v. VanhooseMontgomery County Common PleasTimothy N. O’Connell2009CV01718 2/23/2010Favorable to Plaintiff
Medicaid reimbursement    OAC 5101:3-1-607/1/2009 
Journal Entry Regarding Motion to Determine the Application of Robinson v. Bates to the Present ActionGamble v. RubyFranklin County Common PleasRichard A. Frye08CVC-08-12380 1/29/2010 
JE Denying Motion to Compel Discovery of Collateral SourcesTornow v. Evans Landscaping, et al.Seneca County Common Pleas CourtJudge Kelbley  1/1/1900Favorable to Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Memorandum Contra Defendant’s Motion to Compel and Plaintiff’s Request for a Protective OrderCunningham v. McConnellJefferson County Common PleasDavid E. Henderson05 CV 00359 6/1/2006 
OpinionRoss v. Nappier11th Dist. Court of Appeals, Geauga CountyMary Jane Trapp; Cynthia Westcott Rice, Colleen Mary O'Toole concurring2008-G-28712009-Ohio-699512/31/2009 
Journal EntryFryberger CacchioneLorain County Common PleasMark A. Betleski08CV159254 1/19/2010Favorable to Defendant
Reply Brief of Appellant Patricia A. MantonManton v. JaquesOhio Supreme Court 2009-0820 12/23/2009Favorable to Defendant
House Bill 361 Representative Murray Sponsor Testimony     12/15/2009Favorable to Plaintiff
Judgment EntryBowen v. LohreyMonroe County Common PleasJulie R. Selmon2007-320 12/15/2009Favorable to Plaintiff
Plaintiffs’ Motion in Limine to Exclude Collateral Source MaterialBowen v. LohreyMonroe County Common PleasJulie R. Selmon2007-320 11/9/2009Favorable to Plaintiff
Brief of Amicus Curiae Elk & Elk Co., Ltd., in Support of Appellee Richard JaquesManton v. JaquesOhio Supreme Court 2009-0820 12/7/2009Favorable to Plaintiff
Brief of Amicus Curiae, Ohio Association for Justice in Support of Plaintiff-Appellee, Richard JaquesManton v. JaquesOhio Supreme Court 2009-0820 12/7/2009Favorable to Plaintiff
Merit Brief of Appellee, Richard JaquesManton v. JaquesOhio Supreme Court 2009-0820 12/7/2009Favorable to Plaintiff
Brief of Amicus Curiae, Nicholas J. Schepis, in Support of Appellee, Richard JaquesManton v. JaquesOhio Supreme Court 2009-0820 12/4/2009Favorable to Plaintiff
Merit Brief of the Amicus Curiae Ohio Association of Civil Trial Attorneys in Support of the Appellant Patricia A. MantonManton v. JaquesOhio Supreme Court 2009-0820 10/16/2009Favorable to Defendant
Brief of Amici Curiae, Ohio Hospital Association, Ohio State Medical Association, and Ohio Osteopathic Association, in Support of Appellant Patricia A. MantonManton v. JaquesOhio Supreme Court 2009-0820 10/19/2009Favorable to Defendant
Merit Brief of Amicus Curiae the Academy of Medicine of Cleveland & Northern Ohio in Support of Appellant Patricia MantonManton v. JaquesOhio Supreme Court 2009-0820 10/9/2009Favorable to Defendant
Merit Brief of Appellant Patricia A. MantonManton v. JaquesOhio Supreme Court 2009-0820 10/16/2009Favorable to Defendant
OrderKeck v. PetersSummit County Common PleasTom ParkerCV 200903 1847 9/10/2009Favorable to Defendant
Plaintiff's Motion in Limine re Reasonable Value of Medical ExpensesCundiff v. BartolomucciSummit County Common PleasPatricia A. CosgroveCV-2006-01-0430 3/26/2007Favorable to Plaintiff
Motion in Limine (Collateral Benefits That Are Subject To A Contractual Right of Subrogation)Stebner v. Westfield National Insurance CompanySummit County Common PleasMary F. SpicerCV-2006-08-4849  1/31/2008Favorable to Plaintiff
Plaintiffs’ Motion in Limine Regarding Reasonable Value of Medical ExpensesNeese v. Grange InsuranceLicking County Common PleasJon Ray Spahr2005 CV 00002 6/4/2007Favorable to Plaintiff
Journal EntryMiller v. FergusonStark County Common PleasFrank G. Forchione2008 CV 4815 7/31/2009Favorable to Plaintiff
12345678
Login    Register
Lost Password?


Most files in the archive are in PDF or MS Word form. The following links will take you to places where you can download viewers you may need to read the files archived here.

MS Word 2003 viewer

MS Word 2007 viewer

MS Office 2007 Compatability Pack
Allows users of the Microsoft Office XP and 2003 to open, edit, and save files in Office 2007 formats

More MS Office file viewers




Latest Documents

Jensen v. Hydracrete Pumoing Co., Inc.
Cuyahoga County Common Pleas
Journal Entry
Judge: Brian J. Corrigan

Added: 3/9/2010 6:08:08 AM

Heenan v. Vanhoose
Montgomery County Common Pleas
Entry Granting Plaintiff's Motion in Limine Regarding Insurance Payments
Judge: Timothy N. O’Connell

Added: 2/24/2010 7:58:35 AM



Medicaid reimbursement
Judge:

Added: 2/9/2010 9:02:19 PM

Gamble v. Ruby
Franklin County Common Pleas
Journal Entry Regarding Motion to Determine the Application of Robinson v. Bates to the Present Action
Judge: Richard A. Frye

Added: 2/9/2010 8:48:54 PM

Tornow v. Evans Landscaping, et al.
Seneca County Common Pleas Court
JE Denying Motion to Compel Discovery of Collateral Sources
Judge: Judge Kelbley

Added: 2/9/2010 10:59:21 AM



Latest Comments

, Medicaid reimbursement
NB: subsections (C) and (D)
Added: 2/9/2010 9:01:58 PM

Burk v. Intermed Associates, Inc.,, Plaintiff’s Motion in Limine to Prohibit Evidence Regarding Collateral Benefits with Memorandum in Support
Granted 2/8/2008
Added: 11/11/2009 12:28:02 PM

Baird v. Henretty, Plaintiff's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Instanter
Granted 06/23/2009
Added: 11/11/2009 11:52:10 AM

Horvath v. Staib, Decision
NB: Decision is subject to change, if contractual right of subrogation is challenged and not proven.
Added: 10/8/2009 5:52:41 PM

, Plaintiff's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence of Any and All Payments Made by Collateral Sources
Submitted by Peter D. Traska, Elk & Elk
Added: 7/30/2009 8:37:47 AM